Robert service's comrades tells the story of world communism -- but leaves the reader still hungry for explanations of why the movement lasted so long and what, if anything, it accomplished. The essay on why did the us fail to save south vietnam from communism on its own this was because america supported the diem regime in south vietnam, a catholic repressive government system, and a puppet state. The essay on why did the us fail to save south vietnam from communism the other hand was highly supported within vietnam and thus these reasons state why vietnam could not and would not be saved from communism.
The nsa and fbi were running a wiretapping scheme on the south vietnamese leadership in south vietnam and in the us president johnson taped and recorded everything he did so that historians would have day-to-day insight into decisions that were made. The vietnam war (1955-1975) is probably the most problematic of all american wars first, it is morally ambiguous it was both a war against communism and a war to suppress nationalist self-determination. Why did we plunge into a war to support a regime--s south vietnam--that we had created and that had demonstrated little or no capacity to earn popular support 1 containment--necessity of maintaining worldwide balance of power between us and the soviet union. In 1949, mao zedong led the peoples revolution, which established a communist state in china communism has now been introduced to asia in this period, after world war ii, communism was a popular ideology being introduced throughout the world vietnam was one of the many countries under the threat.
The us failed to save the south from communism due to many interconnected reasons america did not have the ordinary vietnamese on their side, and like the french and japanese before, they were seen as 'foreign occupiers. I am responding to issues in the comment: why was it so important to the us thenvietnam and korea were poor countries and their conversion to communism were their own affairs why sacrifice so many american lives to prevent the spread of communism. Communism in vietnam has played a key role in the politics of vietnam since independence the srvn government implemented a stalinist dictatorship of the proletariat in the south as they did in the north the network of security apparatus (công an) controlled every aspect of people's lives communities of vietnamese refugees arrived in. The vietnam war: american democracy and hegemony: thought that the us was intent on winning a military victory and maintaining a puppet regime in south vietnam 13 he did not make this claim himself, but neither did he contradict it most likely, that was because the south vietnamese government was a puppet regime when ho chi minh. Us containment failed because of the communist superpowers (their existence) and the geography of the land being fought on the battlefield (south vietnam) could not be isolated from enemy.
It was believed that ho chi minh would win the election, causing south vietnam to fall to the socialists the election was postponed so that south vietnam would remain as a capitalist territory for a longer period of time. Why did president johnson continue in the vietnam war lbj took over in 1963, inherited kennedy’s problem and advisors, likely he would continue war → determined to win war against communism → stop domino effect. It is the central document of strongpoint containment, as it designated the middle east, south-east asia and europe territories of strategic importance to the us 2 why did the us fail to win a. 1965: retaliatory air-strikes begin against north vietnam, and the first us combat forces (2 marine battalions) arrive in danang, south vietnam escalation of force level ensues, which tops 200, 000 by the end of the year.
South vietnam, officially the republic of vietnam (rvn, vietnamese: việt nam cộng hòa), was a country that existed from 1955 to 1975 and comprised the southern half of what is now the socialist republic of vietnam. The united states did not sign the second agreement, establishing instead its own government in south vietnam as the french pulled out, the united states appointed ngo dinh diem to lead south vietnam. Noone can say for sure what the impact of the us was in viet nam, but if communism had been allowed to move in without have to expend so much effort and resources maybe it could have been much worse r and vehicle crews had the advantage of larger, fixed radios as did artillery men should radios fail, the average infantryman carried at. The vietnam war was a 20-year conflict in southeast asia (1955–1975) between the government of south vietnam and the communist government of north vietnam the north vietnamese sought the reunification of the two countries under its form of rule. At the peak of the fighting, in 1969, the us was using 550,000 of its own military personnel, plus 897,000 from south vietnam’s army and thousands more from south korea and other allies.
This question is very imprecise i think you are asking why the us failed to prop-up the anti-communist government in south vietnam this is an incredibly complex and in-depth subject, so just. It was total war against south vietnam in that hanoi wished to eliminate south vietnam as an independent and noncommunist political entity, whereas the war the drv waged against the united states was limited in that its objective was simply to compel us withdrawal. The us sent its troops to vietnam to help the corrupted south vietnam dictator against the vietminh, and at the end, the us people started to question why they were in vietnam in the first place the us lost the war, and vietnam fell into communism.
Why did america succeed in korea but fail in vietnam american political leadership didn’t abandon south korea like it did south vietnam though unpopular and costing over 35,000 american lives, south korea was saved from communist oppression because america remained committed to it—unlike south vietnam, which us political leadership. From vietnam, and the consequent collapse of south vietnam to communism 1 carl von clausewitz, on war (princeton, new jersey: princeton university press, 1976), p 143. Thereafter, north vietnam’s only hope was to conquer south vietnam by means of conventional military campaigns, which the united states successfully thwarted in the united states, public opinion grew opposed to the costs in blood and treasure of the controversial war.